SPOILERS || Quest support

[Kiwiana]

Phew, so I formed the code for both options, but getting weird results for both and of course both were not taken in the quest xD

1. Option: CAROLMNPQSTUVWXYZBDEFGHIJK (starting with M after CAROL)
2. Option: CAROLBDEFGHIJKMNPQSTUVWXYZ (starting with the normal Alphabet after CAROL, which is B, cus I have to skip A)

then I write ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ under it
and solve f. e. the first letter of the first part of the code PXHLGLB

1. Option P = Y
2. Option P = N

second letter would be
1. Option X = I
2. Option X = X

Is this correct so far? (I would hide it under a spoiler, but I can't find that option)

EDIT: okay, checked both closely, found a mistake in each, tried both again and again both didn't work.
Do I perhaps have to take out the comma? Or the blanks between the words?